Religious Freedom

People have the right to their own religious beliefs, but everyone also has the right to be free from the religious beliefs of others.

As Catholics, we respect the separation of church and state and value religious pluralism. The Catholic hierarchy, however, has spent years redefining what religious liberty means—pursuing religious freedom protections for large institutions at the expense of individuals.

Catholics for Choice believes that protections for religious freedom extend to one’s personal religious beliefs and practices. They do not give license to institutions like the Catholic hierarchy to obstruct or coerce the exercise of an individual person’s conscience.

Questions about Religious Freedom

We've compiled these talking points to help inform Catholic conversations about religious freedom.

As Catholics, we believe religious freedom is a two-sided coin—it means freedom of religion and freedom from religion for each individual. Everyone has the right to live according to their own beliefs and consciences, and they also have the right to live free from having the religious beliefs of others imposed on them.

Every individual person’s conscience matters. Catholics trust people to make decisions about their personal wellbeing and health care. We may or may not agree with them, but it is each person’s right to make those decisions about their personal wellbeing and health care.

Institutions—both secular and religious institutions, including Catholic institutions—cannot have a conscience. Conscience is sacred to Catholics, and it belongs to a person. What an institution has is a policy, which is very different. Once it is a policy, then you’re dealing with the political or the strategic dimensions of it, but you can’t say that the institution has a conscience.

No, we do not believe in imposing our values or beliefs on others. As Catholics, we believe that one’s own individual conscience is the final arbiter of what is right or wrong.

In fact, this is exactly the point. Many individual providers want to provide the best care for their patients, including reproductive health care and abortion, but they are prevented from following their consciences in institutions that impose policies that restrict patient care. No one should be forced to follow someone else’s beliefs.

Support the work of faithful advocacy

Help us challenge and dismantle religiously-based barriers to safe, legal, and comprehensive reproductive healthcare.

Donate

“The Knights want you to believe any questions about their agenda are an attack against Catholicism. But the truth is that they are diverting tax-free resources to advance an agenda—under the guise of religious freedom—that is completely out of touch with the majority of Catholics.”

“I am an abortion provider. I am Catholic. I am pro-choice because I am Catholic.”

“I am a practicing Catholic who teaches Sunday school, and I have had two abortions late in pregnancy.”

“Looking back, I see my abortion not as something to regret but as an act of survival. It was a decision that allowed me to reclaim my life, and now, through my work, I help others do the same.”

“I know the Vatican’s views on abortion and IVF. My wife and I did not come to the decision lightly. We don’t need any more shaming.”

“If my grandmother had the protection of ending her life-threatening pregnancy, I’d have gotten to meet her. As it is, I can only visit her grave.”

“When I became an abortion doula (a non-medical emotional and informational support person), I did so because of — and not in spite of — my faith.”

“I believe in love, mercy, forgiveness, inclusion, and peace. I trust in God. And I trust women. I pray that my church will too — and soon.”

“I first became aware of Catholics for a Free Choice before I was a Catholic. It was 1974 or ’75.”

“I would like to join Catholics for Choice because it aligns with my beliefs. This group gives me hope.”

“For most of my life, I have attended weekly Mass and Holy Days with very few exceptions. Roe v. Wade passed when I was very young, so I have taken for granted that this was the law of the land. I have always been pro-choice.”

“I spent more than 50 years as a nurse and midwife… I understand that my church vehemently disagrees with my beliefs.”

“I felt no support from my faith. I haven’t gone back to Mass since.

“Catholics have abortions all the time.”

“I have had two abortions, and God loves me.”

“Giving birth at that time in my life, when I was not ready to care for a child, would have been harmful to both of us.”

“It’s been over 50 years. I have not told the whole story of my abortion to anyone, ever. I deserve to heal. It is sad that I cannot go to my faith to experience that healing.”

“She turned to someone in the village without telling anyone, alone and ashamed.”

“My parents, both devout Catholics, and my husband supported my decision.”

“He was my son. I named him, I prayed for him, I mourned him. I let him go.”

“If everyone knew what patients go through, abortion wouldn’t even be an issue that people argue about.”

“When I was a young anti-abortion activist, I believed that I was pro-life, but now I understand that providing reproductive care is the most pro-life thing I possibly can do.”

“I am part of the majority of Catholics who are pro-choice, and our voices should be heard.”

“I do not regret my abortion. That choice allowed me to find religion, allowed me to graduate, allowed me to begin a career — none of which would have been possible if I had become pregnant.”

“I’m a single mom… The Catholic church isn’t feeding my child.”

“I hold my head high and go to Mass every Sunday.”

“I found out when I was four months pregnant that the fetus was no longer viable.”

“The grace of God includes free will, which makes choice synonymous with Christ.”

“Catholicism is my faith, but we live in a country that was founded on a separation of church and state.”

“Mary was given a choice.”

“Being raised Catholic taught me a lot about loving thy neighbor.”

“I have often wanted to leave the church, but this group and the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice have given me hope to change the church from the inside.”

“When I think about the work of Catholics for Choice, I think about what it means to my sisters, my primas, and every community member who believes in a deep respect of conscience when making decisions about abortion.”

“On my 23rd birthday, I had an abortion. I have always been pro-choice, but that didn’t make it any easier.”

“In my early twenties, I was in an emotionally abusive relationship.”

“I will fight until my last breath for choice. My Catholic upbringing and education call me to.”

“Every clinic shift, I serve someone who thinks that they’re the only person from their parish who would choose to have an abortion.”

“Miraculously, that angel in the white coat did turn up, for which I’m eternally grateful!”